Key takeaways
- Pelargonium (umckaloabo) is one of the more researched herbal cough remedies, but the evidence is mixed: a Cochrane review of randomised trials found overall positive but inconsistent results for acute bronchitis and graded the evidence as low quality.
- Most research used one specific standardised extract (EPs 7630), so results from trials do not automatically apply to other pelargonium products on the shelf.
- There is a liver-safety warning associated with pelargonium products in some countries, so anyone with liver problems, or taking medicines that affect the liver, should talk to a pharmacist or GP first.
- Ivy leaf and mullein have long histories of traditional use, but the published evidence for both is much thinner and of lower quality than for pelargonium.
- No herbal remedy replaces medical care: a cough lasting more than three weeks, breathlessness, chest pain, coughing up blood or unexplained weight loss always needs a GP assessment.
Short answer: pelargonium (umckaloabo) has the strongest, though still imperfect, evidence base of these three herbs, with trials suggesting it may modestly shorten or ease coughs from acute bronchitis in some people. Ivy leaf has some supporting studies but weaker overall evidence, and mullein remains largely a traditional remedy with very little modern clinical research. None of them is a substitute for seeing a clinician when a cough is severe, long-lasting or accompanied by warning signs.
What are these three herbs, exactly?
Walk down the cough and cold aisle in autumn and you will meet all three, often without realising it. Knowing what each one actually is makes it much easier to read a label sensibly.
Pelargonium sidoides (umckaloabo)
Pelargonium sidoides is a low-growing, dark-flowered geranium relative from the grasslands of South Africa and Lesotho. The medicinal product is made from the root, and it has a long history of traditional use for respiratory complaints. In Australia it is one of the few herbal medicines to hold a full registration, meaning safety, quality and efficacy were all assessed before sale, rather than the lighter “listed” status most herbs carry, according to the Australian Institute of Pharmacognosy. In the UK and Europe you will often see it sold as Kaloba or under the name umckaloabo.
Ivy leaf (Hedera helix)
Ivy leaf extract comes from common ivy, a climbing plant found across Europe. It is widely sold in syrup form, particularly in Germany and other parts of Europe, and is traditionally used for coughs associated with congested airways. The leaves contain saponins, which are the compounds researchers have focused on.
Mullein (Verbascum thapsus)
Mullein is a tall, fuzzy-leaved plant with a very long history in European and North American folk medicine, where the leaves and flowers have been used in teas and oils for coughs and chest complaints. Despite centuries of traditional use, high-quality modern clinical trials in humans are scarce.
What does the research actually show for pelargonium (umckaloabo)?
This is where the picture is most detailed, and most nuanced. The most authoritative summary is a Cochrane review, which pooled results from randomised clinical trials of pelargonium for acute respiratory tract infections. According to Cochrane, the review included ten randomised trials, eight of which were of sufficient quality for analysis.

What the trials found
- Three trials in adults with acute bronchitis showed inconsistent but overall positive results for resolution of symptoms, including cough and sputum production.
- Three studies in children with acute bronchitis also showed an inconsistent but overall positive combined effect.
- Single studies in acute sinusitis and the common cold in adults suggested benefit for resolving symptoms such as headaches and nasal discharge over an extended period.
- Adverse events were more common with pelargonium than with comparison treatments, but none were severe in the included trials.
Two important caveats follow from that. First, the evidence behind pelargonium has been graded as low quality, which means we cannot be confident about the size of any benefit. Second, the review noted that the tablet form may be less effective than the alcoholic extract, though there were not enough trials to prove that.
Why the exact extract matters
As VitaWise explains, most clinical research used one specific product: a standardised aqueous-ethanolic root extract known as EPs 7630. Results from that extract do not automatically carry over to other pelargonium products, which can vary widely in concentration and composition. If you are reading a product claim, it is worth checking whether the label names a standardised extract at all.
Possible mechanisms
Laboratory studies have suggested pelargonium extracts may affect how some viruses attach to cells, alter the activity of immune signalling molecules, and increase the beating frequency of cilia, the tiny hairs that clear mucus from the airways. These are lab findings, not proof of clinical benefit, but they give researchers plausible directions to investigate.
Is pelargonium safe? The liver warning explained
This is the part many shoppers never hear about. Pelargonium products carry a liver-safety warning in some countries. The twist, as the Australian Institute of Pharmacognosy notes, is that no individual liver case has survived independent causality assessment, meaning regulators could not confirm the product caused the liver injury in the reported cases. The warning exists because of the pattern of reports, not because causation has been established.
Practically, that means:
- Anyone with existing liver disease, or taking medicines known to affect the liver, should speak to a pharmacist or GP before using pelargonium.
- Anyone who develops dark urine, pale stools, yellowing of the skin or eyes, or unusual tiredness while taking it should stop and seek medical advice promptly.
- Reported side effects in trials were more frequent than with comparison treatments but none were severe, according to Cochrane.
The Cochrane review also flagged concerns about the safety data more broadly, which is worth bearing in mind when a product is described as “well tolerated”.
What about ivy leaf extract for coughs?
Ivy leaf syrup is a traditional herbal cough remedy, and it has a more substantial research base than mullein, though less than pelargonium. Some older studies of ivy leaf extract have been published, but we cannot cite strong, independent systematic review evidence here, so any benefit remains uncertain. Independent, high-quality systematic reviews comparable to the Cochrane review of pelargonium are lacking.
There is also a safety note worth knowing: as with many herbal remedies, allergic reactions are possible, and it is sensible to check product information and speak to a clinician if you have any concerns. If you have a known allergy to ivy, avoid it, and As with any herbal remedy, speak to a pharmacist or GP before using it if you have an existing medical condition, including liver problems.
The honest summary is that ivy leaf may help ease cough symptoms for some people, the traditional and commercial use is extensive, and the modern evidence, while not dismissible, is not strong enough for firm conclusions.
Does mullein actually work for coughs?
Mullein is the weakest of the three on evidence. It has been used for centuries in teas, syrups and infused oils, and traditional use is the main reason it remains popular today. But “there are interesting compounds in the plant” is a very long way from “clinical trials show it relieves coughs in people”.
There is a lack of large, rigorous randomised controlled trials of mullein for cough in humans, so no confident conclusion can be drawn either way. If you choose to try mullein tea, the sensible framing is that you are using a traditional remedy with an unproven evidence base, not a treatment with demonstrated effect.
One practical caution: mullein leaves are covered in fine hairs that can irritate the throat if not strained properly, and correct plant identification matters if anyone is considering foraged material, since misidentification of wild plants is a real risk. Buying from a reputable supplier is safer than self-harvesting.
How do the three compare, side by side?
Here is a plain-English comparison based on the published evidence discussed above.
- Pelargonium (umckaloabo): the most studied of the three, with a dedicated Cochrane review. Overall positive but inconsistent results for acute bronchitis in adults and children; evidence graded low quality; liver warning exists; results apply best to the specific standardised extract used in trials.
- Ivy leaf: traditional and popular, with some supportive studies, but the overall evidence base is smaller and methodologically weaker; occasional allergic safety reports, as with many herbal medicines.
- Mullein: long traditional use, interesting lab findings, but essentially no high-quality human trials for cough.
If a friend or an online post tells you one of these “cures” a chest infection, that is not accurate. No herbal remedy, and indeed no over-the-counter treatment, can promise to cure a respiratory infection, and antibiotics only help when a bacterial infection is present and a clinician judges them necessary.
When should you stop self-treating and see a GP?
Herbal remedies, at best, sit alongside good self-care for straightforward coughs and colds. They never replace medical assessment. Seek urgent help (999 or your nearest emergency department) if breathlessness is severe, sudden or present at rest; contact your GP surgery or NHS 111 for new or worsening breathlessness that is not severe.
- a cough lasting more than three weeks
- breathlessness that is new, worsening, or present at rest
- chest pain, especially pain on breathing in
- coughing up blood
- unexplained weight loss, night sweats or persistent fever
- a worsening of known lung conditions such as asthma or COPD
If you live with a long-term lung condition and coughs keep knocking you back, it is worth asking your GP or respiratory team about structured support. Our guide to pulmonary rehabilitation and how to get referred in the UK explains one option that has solid evidence behind it. And if you are a current or former smoker, understanding what actually happens to your lungs after stopping smoking will do far more for your cough than any bottle on the chemist’s shelf.
FAQ
Is pelargonium (umckaloabo) proven to work for coughs?
Not proven, no. Cochrane’s review of randomised trials found inconsistent but overall positive results for acute bronchitis in adults and children, and graded the evidence as low quality. It may help some people modestly, but the certainty around that is limited.
Can I take pelargonium with my other medicines?
Talk to a pharmacist first. Pelargonium carries a liver-safety warning in some countries, and anyone with liver disease or taking liver-affecting medicines should check before using it. A pharmacist can also screen for interactions with your specific prescriptions.
Are ivy leaf and mullein safe for children?
Do not give any herbal cough remedy to a child without checking with a pharmacist or GP first, and never to children under a relevant product’s stated minimum age. Children’s coughs that involve breathlessness, wheeze or high fever need medical assessment, not self-treatment.
Do these herbs work better than cough syrup from the supermarket?
There is no strong evidence that any over-the-counter cough medicine, herbal or conventional, dramatically shortens a cough. Most acute coughs improve with time, fluids and rest. Some people feel pelargonium or ivy leaf helps them; the trials suggest modest benefit at most, with pelargonium having the better evidence of the three.
How long should I try a herbal remedy before giving up on it?
Product labels usually suggest a limited course, commonly around a week for acute coughs. If your cough is not improving after that time, or is getting worse at any point, stop guessing and get it checked. A cough that persists beyond three weeks always warrants a GP appointment regardless of what you have been taking.
The bottom line
Pelargonium (umckaloabo), ivy leaf and mullein for cough is a topic where the honest answer is genuinely more useful than the marketing. Pelargonium has real trials behind it and a Cochrane review that says “possibly, modestly, low certainty”, along with a liver warning worth respecting. Ivy leaf sits a step behind on evidence, and mullein is essentially tradition rather than trial data. Whatever you choose, keep expectations realistic, check with a pharmacist if you take other medicines, and treat any cough that lingers or comes with warning signs as a reason to see your GP rather than a reason to switch remedies.
Sources
- Cough (NHS)
- Cochrane: Pelargonium sidoides (Umckaloabo) for treating acute respiratory tract infections
- Australian Institute of Pharmacognosy: Umckaloabo (Pelargonium sidoides), what the trials show
- Australian Institute of Pharmacognosy: Umckaloabo in plain English
This article is general information and not a substitute for professional medical advice.
Editorial note: this is general health information, not medical advice. Our articles are written and checked against published guidance by our editorial team and are not reviewed by a clinician unless the article says so. If your care team has told you something different, follow their advice.

Leave a Reply